Creating a Sanctuary for Silenced Young Woman - an Editorial Review of "Finding Herself"

Book Blurb:

The world was catching its breath from a war that had redrawn borders and left too many empty chairs at too many tables. It was the 1950's. Girls donned poodle skirts; boys sported crew cuts. People sought comfort in familiar routines, traditional roles, and black-and-white images from a box called television.

Not Cate Clark.

Restless and searching for something more, Cate leaves behind an Ireland still scarred from its struggle for independence and steps into the promise of New York City. But before she finds her footing, word from home calls her back to Dublin-her mother is gravely ill.

Returning to the world she thought she'd left behind, Cate is confronted by the heartbreak of love and loss for her country, her family, and a man she can never forget. When her mother dies, Cate returns to New York.

It's on that voyage across the Atlantic that she meets survivors of Ireland's Magdalene Laundries-women whose pain, courage, and strength spark something deep within her. Inspired by their stories, Cate sets out to create a sanctuary for young women silenced by injustices hidden behind the veils of religion and politics.

Spanning the decade and two cities separated by an ocean, Finding Herself is a sweeping tale of love, loss, and redemption. It is a story of resilience, friendship, and the courage it takes to lead your life and shape your own destiny.

It is Cate's story.

Book Buy Link: https://geni.us/EDeqgq

Editorial Review:

Title: Finding Herself

Author: Maureen Heidi

Rating: 4.0

“Finding Herself” by Maureen Reid follows Cate, a young Irish woman who has moved to New York City to chase a different kind of life and maybe figure out who she is outside of Dublin. She’s working in publishing, living with this incredible woman named Nell and starting to build a life when she gets a telegram from her brother Joseph in Dublin that changes everything. This isn’t just a story about going home; it’s about discovering that “home” and the people in it are far more complex and mysterious than you know, especially when you are faced with the monumental task of saying goodbye.

“Nell heard my cries and found me. Nell Walker is a unique human being, a woman hard to describe. She has a presence that doesn’t seek attention but effortlessly draws it. Her warmth is combined with elegance, and the same can be said about her home in Gramercy Park. A home that she opened for me to share and where I have stayed. It is a gift–helping me smooth the transition from my life in Dublin to the one I am seeking in New York.”

This passage introduces a linchpin character, whose strength allows the protagonist to fall apart without completely collapsing. It defines the “New York” side of the story’s central conflict, and provides the practical means for the plot to unfold. Everyone needs a Nell in their life, that friend whose very existence feels like a safe harbor in a storm. Reid writes her with such grace you can almost feel the calm she radiates. Here, she is not just a character but the anchor that keeps the protagonist from being completely swept away by the Atlantic of her grief. The grammar here is solid- it’s a reflective pause in the middle of the panic. The structure is made up of a few longer, flowing sentences that try to introduce a friend; one who doesn’t try to fix your problems, but just sits with you in the dark, and that makes all the difference.

“Mam opened up her arms as if in an embrace. I knew this house was mine the first time I saw it. Like me, it needed to repair itself. It was dark, hollow, and unloved. The front yard was dominated by large, unruly bushes, whose job it was to block any light from entering. Across the street, a pond had been drained, anticipating the need for future buildings that never materialized. Confused ducks would come by, meandering about while searching for their ancestral home. I could relate to their sense of loss. They confirmed my decision. This was the place. This was where I would begin.”

This passage is just beautifully written- the grammar and parallel structure with the imagery of the house is powerful. Cate isn’t just seeing a house; she’s seeing her mother’s soul. The realization that her ‘strong’ mother was once also a ‘dark, hollow, and unloved’ young woman rebuilding herself is a breathtaking reveal. This passage does more to make the reader understand the mother as a full person, than any dialogue could. It’s a beautiful legacy to discover that your parent’s strength was hard-worn, a parallel to the strength you now have to find for yourself.

“It is when the evening is done and all is quiet that it hits me. My mother is dying. I can barely write the words, lest think about what

 They mean. There are moments when I see her trying to hide the pain. I want to fix it, to make it all go away. Cancer is a silent invader, the unseen thief in the night, robbing me of my mother, the woman who could handle anything. This is not an enemy you can face head-on. I watch the woman who once stood so strong begin to fade.”

Reid captures the fog of grief with painful accuracy. The grammar here is a bit more fragmented and the sentences run on in a way that feels totally real, like a thought tumbling out onto the page. The structure moves from despair to a determined, almost desperate, focus on the positive. The impression it leaves is heartbreaking but also so honest about the caregiver experience. It shows the reader the brutal reality of anticipatory grief- that weird space where profound love and profound loss exist in the very same moment. Anyone who has ever been a caregiver will see their own reflection in these words.

“Finding Herself” by Maureen Reid is the literary equivalent of a slow-burn indie movie, driven by atmosphere and mood and prioritizing character over plot. It’s not a flashy story; it’s a quiet powerhouse that sits with you long after you put it down. Reid’s prose is lush and detailed, and while this deliberate pace perfectly serves the emotional depth, readers who crave a swiftly moving plot may need to adjust to its reflective rhythm. The emotions are however spot on. It’s one of those reads that makes you think about your own family and the stories you never got to hear. Definitely a book that will find its way into your heart.

---

To have your historical novel editorially reviewed and/or enter the HFC Book of the Year contest, please visit www.thehistoricalfictioncompany.com/book-awards/award-submission