Discovering Possibilities Amid the Tobacco Fields of North Carolina - an Editorial Review of "The Resettlement of Vesta Blonik"

Book Blurb:

At thirty years old and unmarried, Vesta Blonik' s future looks bleak when her widowed father remarries, sells the family farm, and moves away during the depths of the Great Depression, leaving her behind. Meanwhile, in eastern North Carolina, Gordon Crenshaw is engulfed in despair after losing his wife and newborn during childbirth. Concerned for his well-being, his family commits him to Dix Hill, the state mental hospital. Struggling against his grief, Gordon's disruptive behavior leads his family to seek his release, but they learn he can only be discharged if a suitable caretaker is found. Through connections in the Carolinas and Minnesota, the Crenshaws find Vesta and pose as Gordon, and her suitor, through letters that hide the truth of his situation. When Vesta agrees to marry Gordon, unaware of the deception, she travels south, only to learn the full extent of the Crenshaws' lie after the wedding. Bound by necessity and circumstance, Vesta and Gordon must navigate their new life amid the tobacco fields of North Carolina, confronting their pasts and discovering the possibility of love in unexpected places.

Book Buy Link: https://geni.us/cehCnR

Editorial Review:

Title: The Resettlement of Vesta Blonik

Author: Denise Smith Cline

Rating: 4.5 Stars

Denise Smith Cline’s debut novel, “The Resettlement of Vesta Blonik,” is a heart-wrenching novel set against the bleak, unforgiving backdrop of Depression-era Minnesota. It is not a story of grand, sweeping change, but of quiet, grinding survival. It’s a narrative that grabs not with theatrics, but with the profound dignity of its heroine, a thirty-year-old “spinster” fighting to piece a life together from the scraps others have left her.

Cline’s prose is a perfect instrument for this tale: elegant yet sturdy, unadorned yet deeply felt. She renders Vesta’s world with a tactile authenticity such that you feel the chill seeping through the cracks of the tarpaper shanty, smell the rich scent of the barn, and wince at the raw ache of Vesta’s chapped hands. The novel’s central relationship, between Vesta and her stoic cow, Lottie, is one of the most tender and authentic human-animal bonds one can ever encounter in fiction. Lottie, their only remaining cow has been in Blonik’s family for eight years through which seven of her calves have been sold off. She is significant to Vesta, because she offers companion in a time when her windowed father withholds affection from her. Vesta’s one spark of connection is a fleeting encounter with Mr. Carlson, which awakens in her feelings of longing and self-consciousness. She imagines sharing coffee with him, talking, even just being listened to- things missing from her life.

The novel’s structure is simple, following Vesta’s increasingly desperate attempts to hold onto her home after her father abandons her for a new life. The pacing is deliberate, mirroring the slow, grueling passage of a northern winter. Cline intercuts Vesta’s story with that of Gordon Crenshaw, a man institutionalized in a North Carolina mental hospital after the death of his wife and child. These two narratives connect beautifully and their thematic resonance- both characters are imprisoned by circumstance and the failures of those meant to protect them- becomes a powerful engine for the plot, culminating in a correspondence that feels both surprising and utterly inevitable.

“From inside the house, through a side window, Vesta Blonik watched. She was alone. Pa had taken the wagon into town; they’d sold the Ford the year before so the driveway to the house was empty. The man knocked again. Vesta rubbed the top of one dusty shoe against the wool of her stocking and did the same with the other. She cracked the door and in the cool, early fall air, she smelled the damp wool of his coat. “Yes?” she said.”

This passage perfectly establishes the protagonist’s undeniable isolation and cautious nature. Her gesture of cleaning her shoes speaks volumes about her pride and self-consciousness. She is shown as a “watcher,” someone on the periphery of her own life, setting the stage for her arduous journey to its center. In just those few lines, we get her solitude, the family’s poverty (the sold Ford), and the intrusion of an outside force (the government man) that threaten to disrupt her fragile world. The pacing is slow and observational, pulling us immediately into her hesitant point of view. Here, the sentences are clean, direct, and sensory and the rhythm is steady and deliberate, using simple clauses to build a clear image without unnecessary flourish. The technical polish is evident; every word serves a purpose. This passage creates an immediate sense of empathy and foreboding.

“She had had only one real suitor, years before. Walter Poindexter

Had been a widower twenty years her senior, and he owned a farm implement store outside Stine. She had never known why he called on her, and she never asked. He was a plump, proper man who wore too

Much hair oil. On his five or six visits to the Stine farm, the two of

Them had walked around the fields and down the road a bit, making polite talk about farming and the weather.”

This flashback is devastating in its quiet humiliation. It reveals the bleakness of Vesta’s prospects through the lens of a man who sees her not as a partner but as a potential corrective to his previous wife’s “profligacy.” It also underscores her loneliness while also highlighting her quiet integrity in defending the deceased woman. The style here remains consistent- clear, unhurried, and slightly distanced, reflecting Vesta’s own retrospective and “un-illusioned” view of the event. The description of Walter is precise and mildly comic (“too much hair oil”), which makes the underlying sadness even more poignant.

“She explained that she had tried her best. That she wasn’t sure what was next. Lottie mooed, turned her head, and stared straight at Vesta. Vesta split open a bale of hay and watched as Lottie munched it. She watched for a few minutes before standing to count the remaining bales, doing arithmetic in her head.”

This moment is the heart of the novel. Vesta’s conversation with Lottie is not pathetic but profoundly dignified, revealing her compassion, her desperation, and her relentless, pragmatic will to solve problems, even as her heart breaks. The pacing here is slow and heavy, forcing the reader to sit with Vesta’s anguish and her subsequent, stubborn calculation, and the sentences are short and stark, mirroring the bleakness of the situation.

“The Resettlement of Vesta Blonik” is a remarkable achievement. It is a novel that is both gentle and unflinching. Denise Smith Cline has written a character in Vesta who will stay with readers for a long time, notably not as a symbol of struggle, but as a fully realized, deeply human testament to the resilience of the human spirit. While the dual narrative with Gordon is slightly less immediate than Vesta’s, its purpose becomes beautifully clear, weaving a broader tapestry of American despair and hope in the 1930s. This is a powerful, assured, and deeply compassionate debut that earns its ending, offering not a facile happily-ever-after, but a hard-won and deeply satisfying measure of peace. It is, quite simply, a beautiful book.

---

To have your historical novel editorially reviewed and/or enter the HFC Book of the Year contest, please visit www.thehistoricalfictioncompany.com/book-awards/award-submission