The Machinery of Racism - an Editorial Review of "Skulls and Gulls"

Book Blurb: Coming Soon

Book Buy Link: Coming Soon

Editorial Review:

Title: Skulls and Gulls

Author: Joseph Kovler

Rating: 4.4

"Skulls and Gulls" by Joseph Kovler, a historical fiction set in September 1938 follows Samuel Cohen Bernstein, a Jewish reporter for the Brooklyn Daily Eagle. Through him, the book explores the machinery of racism, the corruption of institutions, and the possibility of reckoning. The novel depicts how prejudice masquerades as research, granting legitimacy to violence under the language of "improvement," a word its proponents carry like a trophy.

Sam arrives at Montauk Manor on assignment from his editor, tasked with covering the Fourth International Eugenics Conference. He enters the hallway expecting academic lectures, but what he finds instead is a collaboration between American academia and Nazi ideology, which is being conducted openly.

"Sam felt his stomach tighten... Sam scanned the room before sitting down. Professors from Ivy League universities... A few German delegates stood near the back wall, speaking quietly among themselves. Unabashed, they wore small swastika pins on their lapels... ''The other major focus of this conference concerns Jewish populations and the challenges they pose to European and American racial stability.”"

The reader senses that the forces aligned against Sam are deeply entrenched, endorsed by the most respected voices in the country who are not afraid to hide their affiliations or conceal their pins. When the speaker announces the focus on Jewish populations, the reader feels the air shift from abstract ideology to direct threat, even as Sam finds himself named as a problem that needs to be solved urgently.

"Anna covered her mouth. 'Oh, my God.' Sam walked forward slowly. A skull lay near his boot, its empty eye sockets staring up at the sky. Neither of them spoke for a moment. 'What should we do?' Anna stared up at the sky and the parting clouds and whispered reverently, 'The Watcher.'"

This moment comes in the aftermath of a storm that struck when the conference was concluding, forcing the eugenicists to load their collection of bones into a truck and attempt to leave Montauk. The truck overturns on the road and the bones, stolen from indigenous graves and catalogued by researchers spill down the hillside and into the most unexpected place. Anna, who works at the Wyandannee Inn, a simple seaside guesthouse where Sam is staying and who serves as his guide to Montauk's hidden history alongside her cousin Daniel, stands beside him. The moment feels consequential, answering to a question the novel keeps asking- who or what will set things right and do what the courts have been unable to do. Here, the storm becomes, not an agent of destruction, but of reckoning, its convergence of place and timing suggesting something beyond a mere coincidence.

“They want control,” Sam said. “They use what they call science to justify it. Sterilization laws. Marriage restrictions. Segregation. Even the idea that certain people should simply disappear.” “Disappear?” “They believe only certain people should reproduce,” “They call it improving the human race. Controlled breeding.” “Like livestock?” “Exactly.”

This moment takes place near the edge of the cliff in front of the Montauk Lighthouse. Sam is explaining to Anna the full scope of the eugenics movement. He has attended several lectures and now distills the ideology into its brutal essentials. The reader sees that the novel is not content to treat eugenics as a historical curiosity, instead names it as a program of elimination, a logic that moves from classification to sterilization, and from sterilization to something worse. This conversation is not abstract but a warning about what is already in motion.

In "Skulls and Gulls," Kovler has constructed a narrative that places the machinery of eugenics under direct examination. His voice moves with efficiency, grounding the historical reality of 1938 Long Island in the precise details of conference programs, anatomical procedures, and the mechanics of a natural phenomena that still ranks among the deadliest in American history. The structure layers three forces against each other, including the intellectual arrogance of the eugenicists, the street-level resistance of those who opposed and distracted the gatherings, and what emerges as the older, deeper authority of nature. The most outstanding characters in the story are defined by what they refuse to accept, and by concrete acts of witness that ensure the truth does not vanish with the ruins of the ideology of "improvement." Readers who appreciate historical fiction where ideas are treated as battlegrounds, where the natural world acts as both witness and agent of reckoning, and where the central question is not whether justice will come but what form it will take, will find much to consider in "Skulls and Gulls."

---

To have your historical novel editorially reviewed and/or enter the HFC Book of the Year contest, please visit www.thehistoriccalfictioncompany.com/book-awards/award-submission