Memories of Sicily Into the Heart of America - an Editorial Review of "My Sicilian Father"

Book Blurb:

My Sicilian Father is a sweeping, multi-generational historical novel that traces the odyssey of a Sicilian immigrant family as they navigate the trials, triumphs, and transformations of 20th century America. Beginning in the sun-drenched hills of Sicily, where olive groves and stone villages whisper of centuries of tradition, the narrative follows a proud patriarch who leaves behind his ancestral homeland in search of opportunity across the Atlantic. His journey carries him to the crowded tenements of New York and the working-class neighborhoods of New Jersey, where the rhythms of immigrant life pulse with both hardship and hope.

Through his eyes—and later through the voices of his children and grandchildren—the story unfolds as a testament to resilience, sacrifice, and enduring love. The family confronts the devastating Spanish flu pandemic, which sweeps through their community with merciless force, testing bonds of faith and survival. They endure the tragedy of the infamous shirt factory fire, a catastrophe that exposes the brutal realities of industrial labor and the fragile lives of immigrant workers. The despair of the Great Depression casts long shadows over their dreams, forcing them to reinvent themselves in the face of economic ruin. And as two world wars erupt across continents, the family is torn between loyalty to their adopted homeland and the lingering ties to their Sicilian roots.

Yet amid these upheavals, the novel celebrates the quiet victories of everyday life: the laughter around a crowded kitchen table, the aroma of simmering tomato sauce that carries memories of Sicily into the heart of America, the pride of a son graduating from school, and the bittersweet joy of a daughter’s wedding. Each generation wrestles with questions of identity—what it means to be Sicilian, what it means to be American, and how to reconcile the two without losing either.

The patriarch’s legacy becomes not only a story of survival but also a mirror to the immigrant experience itself: marked by hardship, illuminated by hope, and defined by the unyielding pursuit of dignity. His children inherit both his burdens and his dreams, carrying forward traditions while forging new paths in a rapidly changing world. The novel’s lyrical prose and emotional depth invite readers to reflect on the meaning of home, heritage, and humanity in an era of relentless change.

Ultimately, My Sicilian Father is more than a family saga—it is a meditation on belonging, a chronicle of endurance, and a love letter to the generations who built lives from nothing but determination and faith. It asks us to consider how the past shapes the present, how memory becomes legacy, and how the immigrant spirit continues to define the American story.

Book Buy Link: https://geni.us/15BEr6

Author Bio:

Salvatore Tagliareni is a story teller, writer, business consultant, art dealer, and former Catholic priest. For over 25 years he has successfully engaged private and public companies in their search for outstanding performance. A gifted speaker, he is blessed with a great sense of humor and can invigorate an audience with insights on life and leadership. Salvatore was profoundly influenced by his relationship with Dr. Viktor Frankl, the celebrated psychiatrist and author of "Man’s Search for Meaning." The desire to humanize the memory of those who perished in the Holocaust was the driving force behind the novel Hitler’s Priest.

Salvatore is the former president of Next Step Associates an organizational consulting firm. For 25 years he performed strategic planning and organizational design and implementation for many large International companies such as Johnson and Johnson, IBM, Hoffman La-Roche and Boston Financial.

As a young Catholic priest studying theology in Rome, his life was forever changed when the tragic and unexpected death of his best friend led him to seek and gain mentorship from Dr. Frankl. Dr. Frankl and other Holocaust survivors changed the course of Salvatore’s life as they shared their personal horrors under the Nazi regime.

After leaving active ministry as an ordained Catholic priest in 1970, Salvatore went on to earn a Ph.D. in Leadership and Organizational Behavior and had a successful career as an international business consultant. Salvatore lives in Washington, DC with his wife of 40 years and returns to Europe as often as possible.

S.J. Tagliareni.: My Sicilian Father

Author: S.J. Tagliareni

Rating: 4.1

What would you do if an escaped fugitive held your two youngest sons in your own barn, their small wrists bound with rope while you stood helplessly by? That is the nightmare that opens “My Sicilian Father: Exile in America, the Promised Land” a novel by S.J. Tagliareni. It is not merely a dramatic hook but a fracture that reshapes a whole family’s legacy, altering the course for generations. It is a sweeping historical novel and a multi-generational saga that follows the Tagliareni family, from the sunbaked hills of Sicily to the gritty streets of Jersey City and in many ways back again. It explores exile, injustice, reinvention, and the fragile architecture of reputation. But before it stretches across oceans and decades, Tagliareni narrows the lens. He begins in a barn. 

“Rosario hesitated. His hands trembled as he bound his sons, the rope biting into their small limbs. He couldn’t believe the cruelty. 

Verlingo watched, unmoved. There would be a moment—there was always a moment—when the killer’s guard would drop. And when it did, Rosario would strike. He caught Vito’s eye and gave a subtle nod. The boy understood. When the time came, they would move.” “The police opened fire. Seven shots. Verlingo died instantly. Rosario rushed to his sons, untying them, pulling them into his 

Arms. “It’s over” …This part of the story had ended, but the saga of legacy, survival, and betrayal was far from finished.”

The novel begins with a sense of palpable tension as farmer Rosario confronts fugitive and former under-boss Nicolo Verlingo, a vicious killer who has escaped from a maximum-security prison. On his way out of the prison, Verlingo slit the throats of Father Anthony Padovano, a chaplain who had come to hear his confession, and Vittorio Rufino, a young policeman and father of three. Violence follows him like a shadow. This moment in the barn loft carries devastating emotional weight. The setting is transformed from a place of labor and provision into a chamber of fear, and yet within that inversion, something powerful emerges- a silent communication between father and sons. Here, the moral strength of Rosario, the emotional resilience of his children and the corrosive presence of violence are firmly established. Unbeknownst to them however, is that in days to come, that brief exchange will ripple far beyond the barn walls, the trust established will carry the boys across an ocean, and the injustice born in that loft will ensure that the family’s legacy will never gain follow a straight-forward path.

As you read on, you quickly realize that the barn was only a beginning and that what began in the hayloft did not end in violence, rather, it evolved into exile, immigration, labor and resilience. The boys who once stayed bound by fear grow into men shaped by hardship, labor and loyalty until one day tragedy arrived in a different form.  

“Sal, 

If you’re reading this, it means you’ve hit the wall… You carry the world like it owes you something. You laugh to keep from crying. You turn to chaos because you believe only it hears you. But listen to me now. You are more than charming. More than fire. You are my blood. You are the boy who used to steal apples and give them to the hungry. You are the man who stayed when others ran. 

The laundry isn’t just a business. It’s a promise. To the people who work there. To the ones who can’t afford clean clothes but still show up to church proud. Don’t let it die… you’re a Tagliareni. And we don’t flinch.”

This letter feels like a voice that arrives at the precise moment when the youngest brother Salvatore, stands on the brink of collapse. Vito names his weaknesses without cruelty, and that is what makes the letter so disarming. There is no accusation in his voice. You sense that he sees his brother clearly perhaps more clearly than Salvatore sees himself. In doing so, the letter transforms grief from a paralyzing force into a summons to responsibility. It offers a shift that is critical, without which the trajectory of the family could collapse. It also reinforces one of the novel’s central themes- identity as inheritance, as Vito appeals to lineage – “you’re a Tagliareni.” That matters. 

“Rosario did not cry—not then. He sat beside her for hours, murmuring stories from their youth, as if she might still be  listening. In the days that followed, he moved through the house like a ghost, his grief tucked behind polite smiles for the grandchildren, behind nods at the dinner table. He wore her rosary around his wrist like a talisman and spoke to her photograph each morning.”

This passage captures something profoundly true about the way Rosario mourns, not in spectacle or collapse, but in the disciplined redirection of feeling into a routine, that sees his grief resist to erupt but instead settle beneath the surface, concealed behind polite smiles for grandchildren and steady nods at the dinner table. The rosary wrapped around his wrist like a talisman and the daily conversations he conducts with a photograph do not emerge like grand gestures of sorrow but small, deliberate acts that begin to resemble the architecture of survival itself. The prose remains restrained, almost clinical in its refusal to dramatize what could easily become sentimental, and it is precisely that restraint that intensifies the emotional impact. Rosario has survived violence in a barn, exile under suspicion, the humiliation of false accusation, the disorientation of migration, and the relentless labor of rebuilding a life from fractured beginnings, and in each of those crises he responded with action. But here, for a moment, his strength has nowhere to go and in a novel concerned with inheritance and memory, it demonstrates that legacy is sustained not only through courage but through daily remembrance.

At its heart, this novel is about exile, not just the kind that moves you across oceans but the kind that settles quietly inside you. Rosario’s wrongful conviction and his forced exile to run a state dairy farm near Mount Etna felt like a metaphor for the immigrant condition itself, where you find yourself being torn from what you know, what shaped you, and having to build meaning again in unfamiliar soil. There’s something painfully recognizable in that. The novel begins with the sharp urgency of a thriller, but as it moves into the family’s life in America, the pace softens into something more reflective, more lived-in. And the characters truly do feel alive. Vito grows into the family’s steady center, Salvatore, on the other hand never quite shakes the memory of that barn loft. You feel how it stays with him but in the way he protects, in the way he loves, in the way he refuses to let things fall apart. Even the secondary characters leave an impression. Don Campanella brings menace and tension, while Sid Lehmann adds warmth and loyalty, and neither ever distracts from the emotional gravity of the Tagliareni family itself.

“My Sicilian Father: Exile in America, the Promised Land” by S.J. Tagliareni is a novel about what survives when almost everything else is taken. It is a story that will reminds us that we are never just ourselves, rather, we are inheritances shaped by those who came before us, carrying their fears, their courage, and their unfinished dreams, even as we pass something forward in return. It is a story that quietly affirms that some bonds, once forged, cannot be broken by oceans, by war, or even by death.

---

To have your historical novel editorially reviewed and/or enter the HFC Book of the Year contest, please visit www.thehistoricalfictioncompany.com/book-awards/award-submission